Cocktail recipe

The Fourth-Quarter Comeback recipe.

The Fourth-Quarter Comeback is sunny, rum-laced and full of fruit without feeling flat, with Bourbon, fresh orange juice and fresh lemon juice giving it a clearer flavour story.

Cocktail recipe 10 mins Mocktail option
The Fourth-Quarter Comeback cocktail image
The Fourth-Quarter Comeback

Description

The Fourth-Quarter Comeback works best when it is treated as more than a list of ingredients. The danger with tropical drinks is that they can become all juice and no direction. Here, Bourbon, fresh orange juice, fresh lemon juice and maple syrup give the serve a clearer shape: fruit for generosity, acidity for snap and spirit for warmth.

The result should feel abundant and sunny, but still balanced enough that you want a second sip rather than a glass of syrup.

Ingredients

  • 700 ml Bourbon
  • 600 ml Orange juice (fresh)
  • 250 ml lemon juice (fresh)
  • 200 ml Maple syrup
  • 150 ml Black Tea (strong cold)
  • Soda Water to top
  • Ginger Ale to top
  • 4 orange slices (wheels, garnish)
  • 4 pieces Lemon Wheel (slices, garnish)
  • 6 mint sprigs (fresh garnish)

Equipment needed

Instructions

  1. What you'll need: • Large punch bowl (3–4 litre capacity) • Ladle or long spoon • Measuring jug • Citrus juicer • Fine strainer (optional)
  2. Either use a large mould to make a large block of ice (day before), or add ice in periodically to prevent dilution.
  3. Squeeze fresh juice for a fresher taste, or buy shop-bought. • 600 ml fresh orange juice • 250 ml fresh lemon juice
  4. Brew 200 ml strong black tea (2 tea bags, 5 minutes). Remove tea bags and allow to cool fully.
  5. Build the punch base in the bowl: • 700 ml bourbon • 600 ml orange juice • 250 ml lemon juice • 200 ml maple syrup • 150 ml cooled black tea
  6. Stir gently for 20–30 seconds until combined.
  7. Too sharp → add a little maple syrup Too sweet → add a squeeze of lemon
  8. Cover and refrigerate for at least 1 hour. Cold punch blends flavours and slows dilution.
  9. <b>Add garnish</b> • 2 oranges (sliced) • 1 lemon (sliced) • Handful of mint (lightly slap leaves to release aroma) • 3–4 cinnamon sticks
  10. Finish just before serving • Place the large ice block in the bowl. • Add sliced fruit and cinnamon sticks. • Slowly pour in 1 to 1.5 litres soda water or ginger ale while stirring gently.
  11. <b>Tips:</b> • Start with 1 litre, taste, then add more if needed. • Too strong → add more soda • Too light → add a splash of bourbon • Needs brightness → squeeze in half a lemon

Recommended glassware

Punch Bowl / Punch Cup
Punch Bowl / Punch Cup (recommended)

A serving format for shared cocktails and party drinks.

1200–8000 ml Large communal vessel or matching small cups.

Best for: Rum punch, festive punches, sangria, batched party cocktails.

Garnish: Best with abundant citrus, herbs, frozen fruit, and decorative ice.

Quick facts

10 mins Easy Approx. 7.2% ABV Large ice block Mocktail option Batch friendly
Love this recipe? Share it with a friend or save it for later.

More ways to explore

Browse related themes and categories for similar cocktails.